Breastfeeding is often portrayed as a natural, beautiful part of motherhood. For many women, it’s something they plan to do, expect to do, and are told is the very best thing for their baby. But what happens when breastfeeding isn’t as easy—or even possible—as they thought it would be? What if instead of being a bonding experience, it becomes a source of pain, guilt, stress, and even trauma?A recent UK study published in Scientific Reports sheds new light on this issue by exploring how breastfeeding difficulties affect maternal mental health. More than 1,100 mothers shared deeply personal experiences in an online survey, and the results are both heartbreaking and illuminating. The study highlights a critical truth: while we’re encouraging mothers to breastfeed, we’re often failing to support them when it gets hard.The Ideal vs. The RealityLet’s be honest: most moms-to-be have heard that “breast is best.” Healthcare providers, prenatal classes, parenting books, and even well-meaning relatives push breastfeeding as the gold standard. And it is full of benefits—for both babies and mothers. But the reality for many moms is that breastfeeding doesn’t come naturally at all.In this study, 87.9% of participants had planned to breastfeed during pregnancy. But less than 40% said they had any knowledge of how to breastfeed before giving birth. Over half didn’t receive any postnatal support. It’s no wonder so many moms described feeling completely unprepared.Mothers expected breastfeeding to be easy, instinctual, and pain-free. Instead, they encountered cracked nipples, poor latching, low milk supply, infections, and tongue ties. Some even said they dreaded feeding time. Others kept trying through tears, guilt, and pain—because they felt it was the only way to be a “good mom.”When Feeding Fails, So Does ConfidenceThe emotional toll of breastfeeding struggles was a major theme in the study. Many moms said their self-worth plummeted when they couldn’t nurse successfully. Some said they felt like failures. Others described themselves as “bad mothers.” One participant shared:“I felt like I couldn’t do what was best for my baby, like a failure.”Another wrote:“I was very upset when I made the decision to stop. I battled with the will to carry on and my pain and discomfort.”This connection between breastfeeding and maternal identity was clear. For many women, being unable to breastfeed wasn’t just a feeding issue—it was an emotional and psychological crisis.The Pressure to PersevereEven when it hurt—physically or mentally—many mothers said they kept going because they felt they had to. Whether from personal values, societal pressure, or fear of judgment, they described feeling “compelled” to breastfeed. The emotional stakes were so high that even supplementing with formula led to guilt and anxiety.One mother shared:“It put a lot of stress on me as I wanted to continue, but it hurt and wasn’t going well.”The pressure to get it right, even in the face of severe pain or emotional breakdowns, was a recurring pattern. Another mom described how she cried every time she had to feed because the pain was so intense.The Role of Knowledge—and the Lack of ItOne of the biggest takeaways from the study was how little many mothers knew going in. Some had no idea breastfeeding could be painful. Others didn’t know how to get their baby to latch or what to do when their milk supply was low. The assumption was that breastfeeding would come naturally—after all, that’s the message many mothers receive.But when things didn’t go smoothly, that lack of knowledge turned into self-doubt.“I felt very low due to the fact that breastfeeding was not the experience I had expected. I felt like I was doing something wrong.”Better prenatal education could help close this expectation gap. As the study’s authors note, knowing ahead of time that challenges may arise can help parents feel more prepared—and less like something is “wrong” with them when those challenges occur.The Physical Toll: When Breastfeeding HurtsIt’s not just mental exhaustion—breastfeeding can be physically excruciating for some moms. Over half of the study participants reported experiencing pain. Many had cracked nipples, infections, or latch issues due to tongue tie. One mom said her nipples were so damaged they were “falling apart.” Another described breastfeeding as “excruciating.”These challenges often led to early weaning, which then triggered guilt or sadness.A mom shared:“I cried whenever I fed her for the first few days as it was so painful, and I would dread the next feed.”It’s a vicious cycle: the more pain or difficulty, the more stress and guilt—which makes the experience even harder.The Silent Suffering: Lack of Support and Fear of JudgmentThe study also found that support—or the lack of it—made a huge difference in how mothers experienced breastfeeding. Many said they felt abandoned by healthcare professionals. Some reported being dismissed or given contradictory advice. Others said they were pressured to continue, even when it was harming their mental health.“I felt abandoned by medical professionals who then judged me for not instinctively knowing how to breastfeed.”Mothers also felt judged by friends, family, and strangers. Whether they breastfed in public or switched to formula, someone always had an opinion—and often, it wasn’t helpful. This judgment created shame, stress, and feelings of failure.The study suggests that real change is possible—but it starts with understanding. Using the COM-B behaviour model (Capability, Opportunity, Motivation), researchers identified three key areas to improve:Education about the Realities of Breastfeeding – New parents need honest, practical info—not idealized versions of breastfeeding. Yes, it’s beneficial, but it’s also hard. Education should include possible complications, pain management, and when it’s okay to stop or supplement without shame.Technical Support and Pain Management – Healthcare providers need to be better trained to identify latching issues, tongue ties, and mastitis. Pain should never be brushed off. New moms need real solutions, not platitudes.Changing the Conversation – Society needs to stop judging moms based on how they feed their babies. That means normalizing formula, supporting breastfeeding in public, and training health professionals to offer compassionate, individualized care.Maternal mental health matters—just as much as feeding outcomes. When moms are suffering in silence, trying to meet impossible standards, both they and their babies are at risk. Untreated postnatal depression can have lasting effects on bonding, child development, and even maternal survival.By better supporting breastfeeding moms—not just encouraging them to breastfeed—we can protect maternal mental health, improve infant outcomes, and empower families to make feeding choices that work for them.You’re Not Failing—You’re Struggling, and That’s DifferentIf you’re a mom who found breastfeeding harder than expected, you’re not alone. If you switched to formula or stopped sooner than planned, you’re still a good mom. Feeding your baby is important, but so is taking care of yourself.The truth is, we’ve created a culture that talks a lot about breastfeeding—but doesn’t do enough to support the people doing it. This study is a call to action: to listen, to educate, and to stop letting moms feel like they have to choose between their mental health and feeding their baby.Best Breast Pumps: Momcozy Breast Pump Hands Free Upgraded Mobile Flow | M9,... eufy Heated Wearable Breast Pump S1 Pro, Slim Hands-Free... Spectra Baby S1 Plus Premier Rechargeable Breast Pump with... Stronger & quieter than previous versions, Select from 3 regular modes, Offers 4 sizes (17/19/21/24mm) and an exquisite storage handbag Groundbreaking HeatFlow technology prevents clogs and boosts your output by 30%, wireless charging case for pumping anywhere, Up to 300 mmHg of hospital-grade suction with adjustable intensity and cycle speeds. Features technology that allows comfortable suction levels that mimic the experience of natural breastfeeding, portable and rechargeable, $229 $279 $264 Buy on Amazon Buy on Amazon Buy on Amazon Momcozy Breast Pump Hands Free Upgraded Mobile Flow | M9,... Stronger & quieter than previous versions, Select from 3 regular modes, Offers 4 sizes (17/19/21/24mm) and an exquisite storage handbag $229 Buy on Amazon eufy Heated Wearable Breast Pump S1 Pro, Slim Hands-Free... Groundbreaking HeatFlow technology prevents clogs and boosts your output by 30%, wireless charging case for pumping anywhere, Up to 300 mmHg of hospital-grade suction with adjustable intensity and cycle speeds. $279 Buy on Amazon Spectra Baby S1 Plus Premier Rechargeable Breast Pump with... Features technology that allows comfortable suction levels that mimic the experience of natural breastfeeding, portable and rechargeable, $264 Buy on Amazon
